An Oregon Horror Story

Jedediah Strong Smith stands as one of the most remarkable yet underappreciated figures in early American frontier history. A fur trapper, explorer, and cartographer, Smith blazed trails across the American West in the 1820s that would later become vital routes for westward expansion. His journeys through the Rocky Mountains, the Great Basin, and the Sierra Nevada contributed immensely to mapping the western territories. However, among his many expeditions, the tragic events that unfolded along the Umpqua River in 1828 stand as a dark chapter in his otherwise illustrious career.

The Life of Jedediah Smith

Born on January 6, 1799, in Bainbridge, New York, Jedediah Smith developed an early passion for exploration and adventure. Unlike many frontiersmen of his era, Smith was well-educated, deeply religious, and maintained a personal Bible throughout his travels. He joined William Ashley's fur trading expedition in 1822, quickly establishing himself as a skilled trapper and natural leader.

Smith's accomplishments were numerous. He rediscovered the South Pass through the Rocky Mountains, became the first American to travel overland to California, and the first to cross the Great Basin Desert. Perhaps most impressively, he was the first to traverse the Sierra Nevada Mountains from west to east. Throughout these expeditions, Smith kept meticulous journals and maps, contributing significantly to the geographical knowledge of the American West.

The California Expeditions

By 1826, Smith had become a partner in the Rocky Mountain Fur Company. That same year, he led an expedition from the Great Salt Lake to California, becoming the first American to enter California by the overland route from the east. After arriving in California, then under Mexican control, Smith encountered difficulties with Mexican authorities who were suspicious of American intentions.

After finally securing permission to leave California to the north, Smith led a second expedition back to California in 1827. It was during the return journey from this second California expedition in 1828 that Smith and his party would encounter tragedy along the Umpqua River in present-day Oregon.

The Umpqua Massacre

In July 1828, Smith's party of nineteen men was traveling north along the Oregon coast, following the Umpqua River. They had successfully trapped and traded throughout California and were returning to the company's rendezvous point with a considerable amount of furs and supplies.

On July 14, Smith's party established camp near the confluence of the Umpqua River and what is now called Smith River. That morning, Smith, along with two companions, Richard Leland and John Turner, left camp to scout ahead for a suitable crossing. During their absence, disaster struck.

According to the accounts of the survivors, the local Umpqua Indians, who had appeared friendly in previous encounters, launched a surprise attack on the camp. The precise motivations for the attack remain disputed among historians. Some suggest it may have been instigated by employees of the Hudson's Bay Company, who saw American trappers as competition. Others believe that cultural misunderstandings or prior conflicts with other trapping parties may have played a role.

Regardless of the cause, the outcome was devastating. Fifteen of Smith's men were killed in the attack. Only one man at the camp survived—Arthur Black, who managed to escape and eventually make his way north to Fort Vancouver, a Hudson's Bay Company outpost.

The Aftermath

When Smith and his two companions returned to camp, they discovered the horrific scene. Narrowly escaping an encounter with the Umpqua Indians themselves, the three men began a difficult journey north to Fort Vancouver, where they hoped to find assistance.

Upon reaching Fort Vancouver, Smith was received with surprising hospitality by Dr. John McLoughlin, the Chief Factor of the Hudson's Bay Company. Despite representing a competing interest, McLoughlin provided aid to Smith and even sent a party to recover as much of Smith's property as possible. This act of humanity amid fierce business competition has been noted by historians as a remarkable example of frontier ethics.

The recovery party managed to retrieve some of Smith's furs and personal items, including his journals and maps—documents that would later prove invaluable to understanding the geography of the western territories. The recovered property was purchased by the Hudson's Bay Company, providing Smith with funds to continue his journey.

Legacy and Historical Significance

The Umpqua Massacre represented a significant setback for Smith personally and for American fur trading interests in the Pacific Northwest. The loss of men and materials was substantial, and the event highlighted the dangers faced by trappers in disputed territories.

Despite this tragedy, Smith's overall contributions to western exploration remained immense. His detailed maps and journals provided crucial information for later settlers and explorers. The routes he pioneered would later be used by thousands of emigrants traveling to Oregon and California.

Smith himself did not live long after the Umpqua incident. In 1831, while leading a trading expedition along the Santa Fe Trail, he was killed by Comanche warriors while searching for water. He was only 32 years old.

Historical Interpretations and Contemporary Understanding

The Umpqua Massacre has been interpreted differently by historians over time. Early accounts often portrayed it simply as an example of "Indian treachery," reflecting the racial biases of 19th-century historical writing. More recent scholarship has attempted to understand the event within its complex cultural and economic context.

From the perspective of the Umpqua people, the arrival of trappers represented a threat to their resources and way of life. The fur trade had already disrupted traditional economies and power balances throughout the region. Moreover, previous negative encounters with white trappers may have influenced their response to Smith's party.

From the American perspective, the massacre represented one of the many dangers faced by those who ventured into the "untamed wilderness." It reinforced perceptions of indigenous peoples as unpredictable and dangerous, perceptions that would later be used to justify policies of removal and confinement.

Conclusion

The Umpqua Massacre stands as a stark reminder of the complex and often violent interactions that characterized the American frontier experience. For Jedediah Smith, it represented a personal tragedy and professional setback, yet it did not diminish his legacy as one of America's greatest explorers.

Today, numerous geographical features bear Smith's name, including the Smith River near where the massacre occurred. His contributions to mapping the American West were substantial, and his detailed journals provided valuable insights into the territories he traversed.

The story of Jedediah Smith and the Umpqua Massacre embodies both the spirit of exploration that drove westward expansion and the tragic consequences that such expansion often entailed for all involved. It remains a significant, if underappreciated, chapter in the complex history of the American frontier.

To learn more about the life of Jedediah Smith and The Umpqua Massacre, check out our video linked below: